Open Letter

28 September 2020

Open Letter to Premier John Horgan

 

The Honourable John Horgan, M.L.A.
Premier British Columbia.

Monday, September 28, 2020

 

Dear Premier Horgan,

We write you today to express our profound concerns about your government’s decision to allow continued construction work at the problem-plagued Site C dam project.

The Site C project is years away from completion, is mired in problems that may be unfixable, and confronts new, potentially horrendous cost over-runs.

When news surfaced in late July of significant “project risk” geotechnical problems at Site C, your government appointed Peter Milburn, a former deputy minister of finance, to take a closer look at the project’s escalating problems and costs.

But the government did not elect to halt the project while those significant problems, and their unknown consequences, were addressed.

As concerned British Columbians and Canadians, we believe that it is extremely premature for your government to rule out cancelling the project. That would be equivalent to handing the project a blank cheque.

The prudent course of action – one that respects Indigenous and Treaty rights as well as the interests of all taxpayers and hydro ratepayers – is to immediately suspend all construction activities at the project. This includes the imminent and critical river diversion. In our respectful view, it is folly to allow that diversion to occur when geotechnical problems of unknown magnitude remain unresolved at the construction site.

We urge you to give Mr. Milburn clear and unambiguous direction to do three things while construction at Site C is suspended.

First, to appoint a panel of three qualified, independent professionals with no direct ties to BC Hydro or contractors at the Site C project to do a thorough assessment of all known geotechnical problems at Site C. Can the problems be resolved at all? If they can, what is required to ensure the structural integrity of the dam as well as the health and safety of all residents and communities downstream?

The independent panel should also provide an estimate on what the required fixes will cost so that your government can make an informed decision that is in the social and economic interests of all British Columbians.

Second, all information prepared by the engineering panel must be made public well before government decides whether or not to re-start the project.

This is crucial because to date the public’s trust in the Site C project has been eroded by a lack of transparency. Progress reports that BC Hydro was to regularly submit to the BC Utilities Commission have been delayed by months. The public has yet to see a single report filed with the provincial Water Comptroller by Site C’s independent engineer. And there has been a virtual cone of silence from the allegedly independent Site C Project Assurance Board.

Lastly, members of the public deserve a full accounting of all the costs incurred to date at Site C, as well as a comprehensive estimate of the costs remaining to complete the project. That estimate must include a transparent accounting of all known geotechnical problems at Site C and the associated costs to remedy them.

Despite years of work to date, Site C’s construction remains years and billions of dollars away from completion. In fact, construction of the earthfill dam itself has not even begun.

The project’s estimated total costs have recently been pegged at $12 billion – virtually double what they were when former Premier Gordon Campbell announced the government’s intention to proceed with the project a decade ago.

The newly-reported geotechnical problems at Site C will add significant, unknown added expenses to the final project cost.

With your government and governments around the world dealing with the harsh economic realities imposed on society by the global COVID-19 pandemic, now is not the time to be digging an even deeper financial hole on a costly project that may, given proper independent scrutiny, be found to be so structurally unsound as to be too risky to complete.

In closing, we urge your government to do the responsible thing and immediately order a halt to all work on the Site C project, pending the gathering of information that is vital to the public interest.

Yours, respectfully,

Robyn Allan, Economist, former CEO of ICBC.
David Anderson, former federal Fisheries and Environment Minister.
Dr. Warren Bell, past founding president, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment.
Mauro Chiesa, retired advisor to World Bank on major projects including hydroelectric dams.
Marc Eliesen, former BC Hydro President and CEO.
Ken Farquharson, retired engineer.
Eoin Finn, retired partner, KPMG.
Vicky Huntington, former provincial MLA.
Vicky Husband, noted conservationist.
Kekinusuqs Judith Sayers, Former Chief of Hupacasath First Nation, adjunct Professor, UVIC.
Seth Klein, author, policy analyst, and adjunct professor, SFU.
Alex Neve, Secretary General of Amnesty International Canada.
Bob Peart, noted conservationist.
Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, Union of BC Indian Chiefs.
Harold Steves, Richmond Councillor and former provincial MLA.
David Suzuki, scientist and broadcaster.
Harry Swain, former chair of the federal-provincial Joint Review Panel on Site C.
Mardi Tindal, Former Moderator of the United Church of Canada.
Chief Roland Willson, West Moberly First Nations.

For extensive press coverage of this open letter, click here.

Add your name to the open letter by signing the petition here:

Sign the LeadNow petition: Stop All Work at the Site C Dam Now

Groups endorsing the letter

Amnesty International Canada – on Site C
Sierra Club of BC  – on Site C
Yellowstone to Yukon Conservation Initiative (Y2Y) on Site C
Wilderness Committee – on Site C
Keepers of the Athabasca
Endangered Ecosystems Alliance
BC Environmental Network – statement
FightC
Peace Valley Environment Association
Peace Valley Landowners Association
STAND
The Leap Victoria
Extinction Rebellion Vancouver
North American Megadam Resistance Alliance (NAMRA)
Kairos BC & Yukon
Sunshine Coast Alliance4Democracy
Commons BC – statement
Rolling Justice Bus

• Related call for independent review of Site C by Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
• Related open letter from water governance and dam experts Karen Bakker, Rick Hendricks Phil Raphals

Signers added to letter after initial press release

Ken and Arlene Boon, farmers, Peace Valley Landowners Ass’n
Wendy Holm, agrologist, editor of Damming The Peace
Candace Batycki, Program Director of Y2Y (BC and Yukon)
Joe Foy, Protected Areas Campaigner, Wilderness Committee
Ken Wu, Endangered Ecosystems Alliance
Hannah Askew, Executive Director, Sierra Club of BC
Caitlyn Vernon, Campaigns Director, Sierra Club of BC
Adrienne Peacock

Peace River Valley